Federico Fuentes, April 30, 2020
Government responses to the COVID-19 pandemic have put into sharp relief their true nature. This is perhaps no more evident than when we compare Bolivia and Venezuela.
Despite having been installed as “interim” president after a coup last November, Jeanine Anez is presented in the media as leading Bolivia’s “transition back to democracy”. On the other hand, Venezuelan president Nicolas Maduro is regularly described as a “tyrant” or “dictator” presiding over an “authoritarian regime”.
Yet, when we compare how these governments have responded to COVID-19, it is clear these labels bear little resemblance to reality.
Bolivia
In Bolivia, the government was quite slow to react to the pandemic and, when it finally acted, did so in an incoherent manner.
Eight days after the first cases were detected on March 10 the government closed the country’s borders and initiated a nightly curfew from 5pm–6am. But the curfew only served to raise the number of people on the streets at certain times of the day, thereby worsening the probability of contagion.
The government then shifted to a complete lockdown on March 22, imposed under threat of large fines (up to $450) and jail time (up to 10 years) for those who did not comply. Police and military were granted special powers to ensure compliance.
By April 11, almost 10,000 people had been arrested for violating lockdown restrictions. In comparison, Bolivia had only carried out 4,800 COVID-19 tests by April 23.
In terms of alleviating the economic impacts of the lockdown, the government did not issue its first social security payments until mid-April. The government has also said it will subsidise basic utilities and provide companies with loans to cover wage bills.
In the midst of the pandemic, health minister Anibal Cruz resigned on April 8, but not before rejecting Cuba’s offer to help the country fight the virus. Hundreds of Cuban doctors were expelled from Bolivia shortly after Anez assumed power.
Cruz later revealed that modelling indicated Bolivia was facing the prospect of 3,840 deaths from COVID-19 within 4 months. He was replaced by Marcel Navajas, who said expanding testing was not a priority, despite World Health Organization recommendations stating it is vital to any strategy to contain the virus.
Bolivia has also been extremely slow to allow hundreds of its citizens stranded in Chile to return home. After initially announcing on March 30 that 150 Bolivians would be allowed in, the government backtracked and said the border would remain closed.
Almost a week later, the first 480 Bolivians were finally allowed to cross, with a further 430 given permission on April 21. Hundreds more continue to wait their turn.
The government, however, has not wasted time in using the crisis to crack down on its main political rival, the Movement Towards Socialism (MAS), accusing it of seeking to break the lockdown to distribute food and other supplies to those who need it.
It also postponed the May 3 general elections. The most recent polling showed MAS candidate Luis Arce as the clear frontrunner (leading by about 15%), with Anez in third place.
Despite supposedly heading an “interim” government, installed with the sole purpose of convening new elections, Anez has used the lockdown–during which protests are banned–to overturn previous MAS government policies. These include lifting the ban on tin concentrate exports; allowing the state public works company to contract work without going to tender; and eliminating certain agricultural tariffs.
The economic minister has also flagged ramping up the use of genetically modified organisms in agriculture, tax relief for big business and increased foreign investment in natural resource extraction, as part of its “recovery” plan. All without any constitutional or popular mandate.
As of April 23, Bolivia had detected 672 cases and reported 40 deaths from COVID-19.
Venezuela
The situation in Venezuela is starkly different.
Unlike Bolivia, Venezuela was much quicker to move, contacting China early to obtain details about how it dealt with the pandemic. On the basis of this information, it obtained a huge number of COVID-19 testing units and personal protective equipment for health workers.
Today, it leads the region in terms of testing, having carried out more than 350,000 tests. Due to this testing regime, it has only detected 288 cases and registered just 10 deaths, despite having a population two-and-a-half times larger than Bolivia.
Rather than focus on punitive measures, the Maduro government has prioritised policies to alleviate the social and economic impacts of the nationwide lockdown that began on March 17. Among the measures it has taken are a 100% wage guarantee for all workers, a moratorium on rent and loan repayments and social security payments for a range of sectors, including informal sector workers.
Importantly, the lockdown has not meant a complete halt to the circulation of people. Instead, doctors, together with local community activists, have been going door-to-door to seek out potential cases of COVID-19. They have been aided by the government’s online Homeland Platform system, through which people can notify authorities if they have any symptoms.
The same system has also been used to gauge citizens’ opinions on certain measures. For example, a poll was taken in mid-April to see if parents wanted schools to complete the schooling year via distance education and, if so, what would be the most appropriate mechanism to use (internet, radio, dropping off books with exercises).
Community activists have mobilised to distribute copies of a government-issued book (also available online) containing 101 measures to prevent the spread of COVID-19. The book is made up of written testimonies from residents of Wuhan recounting how they dealt with the outbreak.
Venezuela, which has experienced a wave of mass emigration in recent years due to the country’s economic situation, had received more than 20,000 returning citizens from neighbouring Colombia and Brazil by April 24. Approximately 600–650 more citizens are crossing the border each day, where they are tested and quarantined.
Given the discriminatory policies of many countries that have left migrants without protection, hundreds more Venezuelans have been flown back from Europe and the United States, in many cases on specially chartered flights organised by the government.
Venezuela has been able to pursue its people-first policy in spite of the fact that its health system has been devastated by extensive trade and financial sanctions imposed by the United States and European nations. Reports estimated the death toll from the impact of the sanctions was more than 40,000 in 2018 alone. Others claim the tally is now more than 100,000.
Because Venezuela represents an alternative to the profit-driven capitalist system, the U.S. has chosen the COVID-19 crisis as a time to ramp up its attacks on the Maduro government.
Media outlets, rather than continuing to distort information, should be actively questioning why the US, amid a global pandemic, is supporting a repressive regime in Bolivia that is proving inept at dealing with COVID-19, while it tightens a sanctions regime that is putting lives at risk in Venezuela.
(Federico Fuentes is a regular contributor to the Australian-based newspaper Green Left Weekly.)
***
Venezuela Faces the COVID-19 With Voluntary Quarantine Without Curfew
Courtesy: Orinoco Tribune (April 18, 2020)
“Without a doubt, the first measure to contain the transmission chains of Covid-19 is quarantine, and we took it in advance on March 16,” Nicolás Maduro Moros, the president of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela, told in the Argentinian multimedia show La Pizarra, led by Alfredo Serrano Mancilla.
The Venezuelan president stressed that unlike other countries, the people of Bolívar abide by this courageous measure without the need to be forced in a repressive manner, and without a military curfew or supression of constitutional rights, as was done in the history of the nation in other circumstances.
“We call it a social, collective, conscious and voluntary quarantine, there has been no curfew or suspension of guaranteed [rights]. NO!. We have appealed to the conscience of Venezuelan families throughout the country and their compliance is 85%, on average, with this quarantine that we have been in for more than a month,” he explained during the exclusive interview with the Argentine multimedia platform this Saturday.
Asked about his health and schedule at this stage of the pandemic, the head of state admitted that he is quarantined like all Venezuelans, although, obviously working on a thousand things, sleeping 4 or 5 hours, exercising, walking, taking advantage of every moment.
“And luckily in good health and in the battle as always.”
The interviewer stated that he was amazed by the admirable situation in Venezuela, being the country with the lowest number of deaths in Latin America with the rate of 0.03% per 100,000 inhabitants. “What is the formula?”
President Maduro’s response was categorical. “I think something important was that we took bold and timely action. We do not enter into philosophical and useless discussions, that ‘if the quarantine this or that’”.
In addition, he explained that four determining and crucial principles of action were implemented:
- True, radical, deep quarantine with all associated prevention and disinfection measures in streets, public spaces, markets, shops and health centers.
- Expanded and personalized screening, now massive, to all suspected cases, with innovative use of the Patria System platform, used by more than 19 million people.
- Availability of a complete battery of medicines and treatments combined with the support of China, Russia, Cuba and other international allies. More than 1,200 additional Cuban doctors joined those in the country and Venezuelan doctors, as well as scientists from allied nations and the WHO.
- Hospitalization guaranteed with 23 thousand beds prepared in public sentinel hospitals, 534 in CDIs or popular clinics, more than 4,000 Intensive Care Units (ICU) together with the private medical-health sector in the first time of working in a harmonious and coordinated way.
The Patria System, whose technological platform allowed sending and receiving electronically, digitally and in real time, the results of a survey prepared jointly with the WHO, so that 19 million voluntarily enrolled to reveal their health status and other epidemiological data, was particularly relevant.
Through this voluntary system (Patria), the Bolivarian government protects the people with financial subsidies, bonds, education and benefits from socialist programs.
“We located a little more than 150,000 suspected cases and immediately, with the Barrio Adentro health system, with more than 25 thousand family doctors, house to house, they have visited more than 140,000 of those cases and performed screening tests on time for all. Many were normal viral cases, but we did extended screening anyway. It is a big data formula combined with the Patria System, applying diagnosis and tests with great results.”
The Venezuelan president considered that this is the formula that Venezuela has been building.
“Based on the experience of China and South Korea. In Latin America, we are navigating this sea infected with the pandemic and no one can feel safe yet.”
(Nicolás Maduro Moros is the 46th President of Venezuela since 2013 and previously served as Minister of Foreign Affairs from 2006 to 2013 and as Vice President of Venezuela from 2012 to 2013 under President Hugo Chávez.)
