Modi Government Is Filling its Coffers at the Cost of State-Owned Firms

The Narendra Modi government is solving one problem by creating another.

At a time when the Indian government’s revenues are low and it needs to increase spending to battle the Covid-19 pandemic, it is banking on state-owned companies to meet its deficit. The Centre has reportedly told eight state-owned companies to buy back their shares, which will help the government – the largest shareholder in these companies – raise funds as it can tender its shares for cash.

In addition, the government has also asked these companies to dole out dividends each year so it makes money on the stake it holds.

While this move could help fill the government’s depleting coffers, the companies could suffer in the long-run as they could have instead used this cash to invest in their businesses, or just keep it as a buffer for tough times.

Share buybacks and dividends

This is not a new phenomenon, experts say. “The government needs to bridge the fiscal deficit and hence does not allow companies to skip dividends,” said Sunil Damania, chief investment officer at data analysis firm MarketsMojo.com. “On many occasions, the government has nudged companies to declare a higher dividend than what they should be paying just to bridge the fiscal deficit.”

State-owned firms, also known as public sector units, bought back shares worth Rs 40,276 crore ($5.37 billion) between the financial years 2016 and 2020 (April-March), according to data compiled by MarketMojo (Table 1).

Table 1: Shares Brought Back by Indian State Owned Companies

Years Buybacks, Rs crore
2016 4,483
2017 18,963
2018 5,338
2019 10,671
2020 822

Dividend payouts – which are optional for all listed companies in India – have also been handsome in the case of PSUs (Table 2).

The dividend payout ratio, which shows how much of their profits companies part with each year as dividends, reveals that PSUs have been dipping into their cash reserves to pay dividends. For example, in the last financial year, Indian Oil Corporation, Bharat Petroleum, and National Aluminum paid its shareholders more than the net profits they earned.

Table 2: Top Five Dividend Paying Public Sector Units (%)

Companies 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016
Indian Oil Corpn. 305 57 102 52 31
National Aluminium 202 69 95 97 65
BPCL 121 61 60 65 33
Engineers India 76 77 73 69 49
Balmer Lawrie and Co. 72 67 62 47 35

These moves, coupled with the government’s intention to disinvest stakes in some of these PSUs in the future, could prove to be a double whammy for these companies.

PSU shares

Unlike in the US, high dividend yields and buybacks do not make companies attractive to retail or institutional investors in India. “If the money goes out of the business (through dividend or buyback), which needs to be re-invested, then the value of a business drops,” a mutual fund manager told Quartz requesting anonymity. “So, this is not good for you as an investor as the dividend does not cover the loss in valuation.”

Now, with the government trying to raise funds in some of these PSUs by selling its stake, there could be an oversupply of shares of these companies, which will lead to a fall in their prices.

This is neither good for the government nor for retail and institutional investors.

“PSU stocks are trading significantly below fair value as the government has been following a wrong policy of selling its own stake in a piecemeal manner,” said Devarsh Vakil, deputy head, retail research, HDFC Securities. “The government is frequently diluting its stake. This policy has led to the destruction of wealth for itself.”

So while dividends and buybacks may provide a quick fix in the short-run, these policies are surely hurting investors and companies in the long-run.

(Prathamesh Mulye writes on economy and banking from Mumbai. Article courtesy: Quartz.)

Janata Weekly does not necessarily adhere to all of the views conveyed in articles republished by it. Our goal is to share a variety of democratic socialist perspectives that we think our readers will find interesting or useful. —Eds.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email
Telegram

Contribute for Janata Weekly

Also Read In This Issue:

Fear Still Stalks Religious Minorities

In the words of activist Harsh Mander, a prominent target of the regime, the “election results of 2024 have not erased the dangers of fascism. The cadres of the Hindu Right remain powerful and motivated.”

Read More »

The RSS and Modi – Two Articles

‘The RSS Sends a Message’: Sangh Parivar’s comments on party strategy and leadership qualities hint at a change in power balance within the BJP and in its equation with the RSS. Also: ‘The RSS Supremo’s Outbursts, a Denial By “Sources” and the History’.

Read More »

If you are enjoying reading Janata Weekly, DO FORWARD THE WEEKLY MAIL to your mailing list(s) and invite people for free subscription of magazine.

Subscribe to Janata Weekly Newsletter & WhatsApp Channel

Help us increase our readership.
If you are enjoying reading Janata Weekly, DO FORWARD THE WEEKLY MAIL to your mailing list and invite people to subscribe for FREE!